Tuesday Idol Thoughts
Ok... started off rough for me... but here's my idol thoughts... loved David Cook... its hard for me to think he's not the front runner at this point. I was listening and thought, "No way... that's Billy Jean. Unreal!" Great choice!
Michael Johns, don't get me wrong, I thought he did an awesome job... but... in my opinion, he brought nothing to it. I mean the judges are always busting people for not bringing themselves to the song... and yet he does the cover pretty much straight and they think he's a genius. Is there some judging bias? Don't get me wrong, I ike the guy... but tonight's performance didn't boost him any in my eyes.
Loved Brooke...Randy's criticism kills me... one week, he tells her he thinks she should have brought the band in, and this week that he thinks she shouldn't. I just think he doesn't like her... but I like her style.
And I always like Jason Castro... but that might be the cool dreads. I thought David Archuleta had a good performance... but as an artist, he's not really my style... and disagree or not, I'm the one voting... or not.
Every one else was ok to me... Who would I send home? Either Kristy or the girl who's name I can never remember. Romelaide?
That's my story and I'm sticking to it....
I'm with you. Thought David Cook rocked it. He has brought so much to this season. Totally unexpected.
David A -- well, he's an amazing vocalist, but just needs more time to mature artistically. At least he didn't lick his lips so much this week.
Randy was just in a bad mood I think -- not feeling well, etc.
I do think that I might have left the band out on Brooke's song, but it may have worked if they had made some changes to the arrangement.
Kristy made a survival choice. I don't see her going home after singing such a huge anthem, even if she hadn't nailed it.
Who's going? I would say Ramiele, Carly or Chikezie.
Posted by: Gary Hodges | March 26, 2008 at 09:10 AM
David Cook got my one and only vote last night (actually, it was the first time I ever voted)
Posted by: Fred McKinnon | March 26, 2008 at 05:05 PM